At Shafer, we understand the importance of providing our customers with multiple solutions that cater to their needs and budget. One of the most common dilemmas faced by homeowners is whether it’s time for an A/C repair or cooling replacement. While there are various factors to consider, such as time and finances, we are here to guide you through the decision-making process. 

Weighing Your Options

When faced with the decision of whether to repair or replace your A/C unit, it’s essential to carefully evaluate several key factors. By considering these factors, you can make an informed decision that aligns with your needs, budget, and long-term goals.

1. Cost of Repairs and New HVAC Unit

The cost implications of repairing your current A/C unit versus investing in a new one play a significant role in the decision-making process. Begin by assessing the extent and frequency of repairs your A/C unit requires. If the repairs are minor and infrequent, it might be more cost-effective to opt for repairs rather than a complete replacement.

On the other hand, if the repairs are becoming increasingly frequent or if there is a major issue that requires significant investment, it might be more prudent to consider replacing the unit. Additionally, factor in the potential cost savings that a new HVAC unit can offer in terms of energy efficiency. Newer units are often designed to operate more efficiently, leading to reduced energy consumption and lower utility bills over time. Thus, you need to weigh the options between new air conditioning costs and air conditioner maintenance costs.

2. Energy Cost Reduction

Energy consumption and the resulting utility bills are a crucial consideration when deciding between repair and replacement. As A/C units age, they tend to become less efficient, leading to increased energy consumption and higher energy costs. Take into account recent increases in energy prices and project how these increases might impact your monthly expenses with your current A/C unit.

Compare this projected cost with the potential energy savings that a new HVAC unit can provide. Modern units are designed with advanced technologies that improve energy efficiency, translating into lower energy bills. By investing in a new unit, you can potentially offset the cost of the initial investment through long-term energy savings.

3. Frequency of Repairs and Lifestyle Considerations

Consider how the frequency of repairs impacts your daily life and overall comfort. Constant breakdowns and the need for repairs can be inconvenient and disruptive, especially during periods of extreme weather. Evaluate the level of inconvenience caused by these frequent interruptions and assess whether redirecting the funds spent on repairs toward the purchase of a new A/C unit would provide a more reliable and stress-free solution.

However, it’s essential to consider your current financial situation. If you find yourself in a tight spot financially, a repair might be a viable option to buy some time before making a larger investment in a new unit. In such cases, working with a trusted company that offers multiple solutions tailored to your needs can help you navigate the decision-making process more effectively. Regardless of your situation, it might be wise to look into A/C unit financing and A/C repair financing. 

Furthermore, consider your long-term plans. If you intend to stay in your current home for an extended period, investing in a new A/C unit might provide you with greater peace of mind and a more comfortable living environment. On the other hand, if you are planning to move soon, a repair could be a more cost-effective short-term solution.

By carefully weighing the cost of repairs, potential energy savings, frequency of repairs, and considering your lifestyle, you can make an informed decision that strikes the right balance between your immediate needs and long-term goals. Collaborating with a reputable air conditioning service company will ensure you receive expert advice and a range of solutions to choose from, tailored to your unique circumstances.


However, if you need more information about the signs that might indicate it’s time to consider a new A/C, our A/C professionals at Shafer Air Conditioning have provided the following list: 

1. Rising Energy Bills:

If your energy bills have been consistently increasing, it could be a sign that your A/C unit is becoming less efficient. Consider the impact of energy price hikes and weigh this against the potential savings offered by a new, energy-efficient unit.

2. Frequent Repairs:

When your A/C unit requires repairs on a regular basis, it not only drains your finances but also disrupts your daily routine. Assess whether the downtime caused by frequent repairs negatively affects your lifestyle. In some cases, redirecting repair funds towards a new A/C unit might be the more practical choice. However, if you’re in a temporary tight spot financially, consult a trusted company that can provide you with multiple solutions.

3. Aging Unit:

A/C units typically have a lifespan of around 10 years. If your unit has surpassed this age, it’s worth considering a replacement. An older unit is more likely to encounter issues and become less energy-efficient over time.

4. Home Comfort Issues:

Hot and cold spots in your home can indicate problems with your HVAC unit or improper ductwork. Seek the expertise of a licensed professional to evaluate your situation and provide appropriate recommendations.

5. Humidity Problems:

A properly functioning HVAC unit should effectively eliminate humidity from your home. If you experience persistent humidity issues, it could be a warning sign that something is amiss. While replacement is one option, there may be repair solutions available. Regardless, this issue requires your attention to ensure your home remains comfortable and free from excessive moisture.

6. Constant Running without Adequate Cooling:

If your A/C unit runs continuously but fails to adequately cool your home, it could signify that the unit is reaching the end of its lifespan or requires repairs. Seek professional investigation to gather more information and make an informed decision. Consider factors such as the unit’s age, frequency of repairs, and budget when evaluating the situation.


At Shafer, we understand the inconvenience of being without a functioning HVAC unit, especially during extreme weather conditions. Luckily, we offer San Antonio through Kyle’s most comprehensive and affordable preventative maintenance plan to enhance the efficiency of your A/C system and identify potential issues before they escalate into emergencies. Additionally, we offer an affordable $89 HVAC Tune-Up, which ensures that your unit operates at optimal performance levels. By availing this service, you can save both time and money in the long run.

When faced with the decision of repairing or replacing your A/C unit, it’s crucial to consider various factors, including repair costs, potential energy savings, frequency of repairs, and your lifestyle. By carefully assessing these factors and evaluating warning signs such as rising energy bills, frequent repairs, and comfort issues, you can make an informed decision. Remember, regular maintenance and timely repairs can extend the life of your A/C unit, while a well-planned replacement can offer improved energy efficiency and home comfort. At Shafer, we are committed to assisting you throughout this decision-making process and providing the best solutions to meet your needs and budget.

Let Us Contact You!

"*" indicates required fields

Give us a call at (210) 660-2424 or fill out the form below and we will follow up via text and phone.
This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.